top of page

Do the Priests of the SSPX Enjoy Supplied Jurisdiction?

Sep 30
6 min read

Updated: Nov 14

Perhaps the most pressing question of all, as Fr. Ramon Angles noted, is whether the Society enjoys the necessary spiritual authority from the Church to dispense the Sacraments. Most especially, the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.

In exploring the question, we have identified three justifications proposed by the Society as the strongest arguments in favor of their ministry, as published in their Apologetics available on SSPX.org. We note, however, that the original justification proposed by the founder, † Msgr. Marcel Lefebvre, is quite distinct from them all.

I. The Teaching of Marcel Lefebvre

The Founder of the SSPX quite unexpectedly proposed the theory that during the time of crisis, the Society, in virtue of their Traditional doctrine and bent, enjoy a Supplied Jurisdiction conferred from the community of the faithful, within the context of general necessity. This even extends to Episcopal Jurisdiction by which an autonomous Bishop exercise vigilance and authority over the faithful in order to "safeguard the transmission of Grace and the Catholic Faith". Truly, therefore, an authority independent of the Catholic Church as such. Archbishop Lefebvre says:

Since the jurisdiction of the bishop is not territorial but personal and has as its source the duty of the faithful to save their souls, if a group of faithful in the diocese calls upon the bishop to have a priest, this group gives by this very fact, authority to the bishop (ce groupe donne par le fait même, pouvoir à l’évêque) to watch over the transmission of the Faith and of grace in this group, by the intermediary of the priest that he sent. (See Full Text)

However, this argument appears to contradict the Condemnation of Pope Pius VI's Auctorem Fidei, which says:

The proposition which states "that power has been given by God to the Church, that it might be communicated to the pastors who are its ministers for the salvation of souls"; if thus understood that the power of ecclesiastical ministry and of rule is derived from the COMMUNITY of the faithful to the pastors, [HERETICAL]. (Auctorem Fidei, Pius VI; Denzinger no. 1502.2)

Auctorem Fidei here makes clear that an argument for Jurisdiction which exists dependently on the consent of the faithful, and a so-called conferral of Jurisdiction from them, contains in itself a proposition contrary to Catholic Faith. As Catholics we cannot safely agree with the teaching of Marcel Lefebvre without necessarily contradicting the Papal Condemnation cited, as is evident in the highlighted portion of Lefebvre's statement above.

II. The Teaching of Tissier de Mallerais

A faithful disciple indeed of Msgr. Lefebvre, a witness to the founding of the SSPX, and long-time formator of the Priests of the Society, Bernard Tissier de Mallerais provides us with a coloratio or adjustment of Lefebvre's argument, by positing that it is not quite the faithful themselves who confer Jurisdiction.

No, he says, it is rather the "Mystical Body of Christ", that is "The Church", by authority from Christ the Head of the Church, who confers Jurisdiction to Traditional Priests - apart and perhaps even contrary to the commission, delegation, consent, or supplying of the Roman Pontiff, and any body or member of the Catholic Church's Hierarchy, precisely by the individual Faithful's need and desire of the Sacraments and the Pastoral guidance of a "traditional Priest". This consent of the faithful to accept the Priest as his Pastor thus establishes a Supplied Pastoral authority, the same as a Diocesan Pastor, which is personal, and not territorial.

However, granting that according to Divine and Catholic Faith, the Church does not believe that any Jurisdiction can exist in the Catholic Church without a commission or delegation from the Hierarchy in union with the Roman Pontiff (Council of Trent, Session 26, Canon VII), such a proposition appears at the very least proximate to heresy, and undoubtedly, an error. Indeed, if we posited that Jurisdiction can exist in the Church independent and contrary to the will of the Roman Pontiff himself (Vatican I Pastor Aeternus, Session I, Ch. 1; St. John 21:17), one necessarily finds himself in the realm of Eastern Orthodox Ecclesiology at best, or some malformed revision of it.

III. The Argument of Fr. Ramon Angles

Serving for many years as Pastor and Rector at St. Mary's Kansas, one of the Society's largest apostolates, serving many families over the years, Angles presents a Canonical argument in favor of the Society's ministry based on Canon 144.

Based on this Canon, Angles presents the case that the Marriages and Confessions of the Society are perfectly licit and valid. Moreover, the rest of the Society's ministry, based on the 1983 Code of Canon Law, enjoys the full extent of the concept of Ecclesia Supplet, whereby the Pope grants the SSPX Jurisdiction for the Sacraments by granting faculties through Canon 144. Hence, in this view, the SSPX does not need to depend on anything but the 1983 Code of Canon Law, resting assured that they have Jurisdiction from the Catholic Church as supplied by Law.

However, there are many Canonical misinterpretations at play in this argumentation, not the least of which is the concept of Common Error.

Indeed, this Canon addresses the faithful of a Diocese, and a Priest whom the faithful believe possesses habitual Jurisdiction, or, Title. In other words, the faithful in question have reasonable grounds to believe Father So-and-so is a Priest incardinated in the Diocese, who would thus possess the necessary faculties to serve their Diocese. In cases where these faithful may not be aware of any censures in place or the factual deprivation of the Priest's Title or faculties, and are thus understandably in a state of Common Error concerning the Priest, they thus trigger Canon 144, whereby the Church, namely, the Pope via the Code of Canon Law, supplies the factual lack of jurisdiction in that Priest, in order that the faithful be provided valid Absolution in Confession, or other acts requiring Jurisdiction. Evidently, this Canon is not referring to independent Chapels.

It should suffice to any of our readers that the chapels of the SSPX, even by the advertisements of the Society itself, do not purport to be communities served by Priests incardinated in the local Diocese. Indeed, they are notoriously understood to lack any Title in the Catholic Church whereby they could possess Jurisdiction. Nor do Priests of the Society claim or act in such a way that the faithful could reasonably be in error concerning their status in the local Diocese. In fact, the faithful are perfectly cognizant of the fact that these Priests are not part of the Diocese, nor could they possibly expect such a thing, as they are intentionally attending an independent Chapel deliberately disassociated with the Diocese.

It is without any doubt therefore that both the Faithful and the Priests are in positive certainty concerning the lack of title and incardination. They are also positively certain that the mass center in question is not a Diocesan Catholic Parish Church or Mission.

IV. The Argument of Fr. Peter Scott

Former District Superior of the USA for the Society, Fr. Peter Scott, presents another argument from Canon Law based on Canon 19, which says:

This Canon allows the interpreter of the Code to apply analogies of Law from the principles of Jurisprudence, previously ratified law, and other sources, to fill any potential gaps in the Code with respect to a particular case. This allows a Canonical Court to apply Justice adequately and in harmony with right reason without adhering strictly to the letter of the Law.

Fr. Scott uses this Canon to make the argument that based on the Church's previous Canonical concessions for Supplied Jurisdiction, a Priest of the Society can presume a supplied delegation from Law to dispense the Sacraments on the grounds of necessity, indeed, so long as need is present.

The most fundamental flaw in this line of argumentation, however, is the concept of Necessity itself, for this concept, by which the Roman Pontiff (the Legislator of the Code of Canon Law), has a determined meaning not only in the intention of the Legislator but in the usage of the term in the Code itself. Hence, Fr. Scott is forced to create an Analogy of Law for a concept of necessity which is not envisioned nor intended by either the Code or the Roman Pontiff - for it is clear that Necessity in Canon Law refers to what is called in Sacramental Theology "necessity of means".

This Necessity means that without this or that Sacrament, here and now, the soul in question stands in proximate danger of the loss of Salvation. Evidently, according to Catholic Theology, such a Necessity exists only for the Sacrament of Penance and Baptism in danger of death. All other cases are not what either the Law or the Legislator intends by this term, and hence the appeals to analogy fail precisely when the term is extended to cases outside of genuine and imminent danger of the loss of salvation. This is the true meaning of Canon 1752's "Salus Animarum Suprema Lex"; namely, that when a soul is in proximate danger of the loss of his soul, and thus needs to receive a Sacrament necessary for salvation, the Legislator intends to supply Jurisdiction.

As such, if we relied solely on Fr. Scott's appeal to Canon 19, we would find ourselves condemning a significant portion of the Society's ministry which takes place without such necessity, that is, with necessity as intended by Law and the Legislator.

Click Here for a full refutation of Fr. Scott's appeal to Canonical Equity. [COMING SOON]


 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page