Ramon Angles' Canonical Study on Supplied Jurisdiction
Updated: Nov 14
On Common Error
Serving for many years as Pastor and Rector at St. Mary's Kansas, one of the Society's largest apostolates, serving many families over the years, Angles presents a Canonical argument in favor of the Society's ministry based on Canon 144, available here.
Based on this Canon, Angles presents the case that the Marriages and Confessions of the Society are perfectly licit and valid. Moreover, the rest of the Society's ministry, based on the 1983 Code of Canon Law, enjoys the full extent of the concept of Ecclesia Supplet, whereby the Pope grants the SSPX Jurisdiction for the Sacraments by granting faculties through Canon 844. Hence, in this view, the SSPX does not need to depend on anything but the 1983 Code of Canon Law, resting assured that they have Jurisdiction from the Catholic Church as supplied by Law. Indeed, Canon 144 says:
Can. 144 §1. In factual or legal common error and in positive and probable doubt of law or of fact, the Church supplies executive power of governance for both the external and internal forum.
However, there are many Canonical misinterpretations at play in this argumentation, not the least of which is the concept of Common Error.
Indeed, this Canon addresses the faithful of a Diocese, and a Priest whom the faithful believe possesses habitual Jurisdiction, or, Title. In other words, the faithful in question have reasonable grounds to believe Father So-and-so is a Priest incardinated in the Diocese, who would thus possess the necessary faculties to serve their Diocese. In cases where these faithful may not be aware of any censures in place or the factual deprivation of the Priest's Title or faculties, and are thus understandably in a state of Common Error concerning the Priest, they thus trigger Canon 144, whereby the Church, namely, the Pope via the Code of Canon Law, supplies the factual lack of jurisdiction in that Priest, in order that the faithful be provided valid Absolution in Confession, or other acts requiring Jurisdiction. Evidently, this Canon is not referring to independent Chapels. As Wernz & Vidal's 1937 commentary on the 1917 Code of Canon explains:
The case of common error. D’Annibale explains common error as follows (Summ. I, 79, note 72): “Common error exists if, in the place where someone exercises jurisdiction (for example, where he acts as parish priest), he is publicly considered to possess it, whether the error concerns a fact or the law, provided that an error of law is probable.” ...thus common error, in the sense of the canon, exists when there is a public fact which of itself is apt to lead into error, not just one or another person, but anyone indiscriminately, so that it is rather incidental that one or another person, owing to his particular circumstances, is not led into error but knows of the lack of authority. (Wernz & Vidal, SJ, Jus Canonicum Tome II, no. 381 "De Casu Erroris Communis")
It should suffice to any of our readers that the chapels of the SSPX, even by the advertisements of the Society itself, do not purport to be communities served by Priests incardinated in the local Diocese. Indeed, they are notoriously understood to lack any Title in the Catholic Church whereby they could possess Jurisdiction. Nor do Priests of the Society claim or act in such a way that the faithful could reasonably be in error concerning their status in the local Diocese. In fact, the faithful are perfectly cognizant of the fact that these Priests are not part of the Diocese, nor could they possibly expect such a thing, as they are intentionally attending an independent Chapel deliberately disassociated with the Diocese, albeit on the grounds of necessity.
It is without any doubt therefore that both the Faithful and the Priests are in positive certainty concerning the lack of title and incardination, and they are also positively certain that the mass center in question is not a Diocesan Catholic Parish Church or Mission. It follows that Canon 144 de facto cannot apply to their situation. Indeed, the concept of Common Error is contingent on objective facts that of themselves necessarily lead into error; it therefore is not concerned with ignorance, or deception. As the Canon Law Society of America's New Commentary on the 1983 Code explains:
Such an error must be probable, i.e., it must be of such a nature that it is capable of gaining the assent of a prudent person. Hence, it is not simply ignorance. The error is to be common, not private; that is, it is to affect some sort of community... That an error is "common" does not mean that majority of those present hold something to be true, but that there is a public circumstance in which all reasonable persons would naturally conclude that it is true. (CLSA, New Commentary, Canon 144, p. 192-193)
Unfortunately, Fr Ramon Angles' article linked above, when discussing this issue, does nothing to prove that Canon 144 applies to the Priests of the Society, but merely takes it for granted that it does, based on the fact that their Priests put on a purple stole, and sit in the confessional. He says:
In the Society of St. Pius X chapels, schools, Mass centers, summer camps, and extraordinary gatherings of faithful in the occasion of pilgrimages, ordination ceremonies, and similar cases, it is sufficient for a priest to sit in the confessional, to put on a violet stole or to give some external public sign which the faithful recognize as an indication that he is ready to hear confessions for a group of people, for common error at least de iure to exist. In many established chapels the common error will be de facto.
Hence, rather than apply the principles of the Canon to the particular case of the Society, he simply states that Common Error includes any instance in which a validly ordained Priest puts on a purple stole, and hence, their Priests have Supplied Jurisdiction, because they too wear a purple stole. To see the laughable absurdity of this argumentation, we refer our readers to the definitions of Common Error quoted above by Wernz & Vidal, and the Canon Law Society of America. Fr. Angles' re-definition, despite having provided truncated Latin quotations of the true definition for his English-speaking readers in his article, fails to distinguish that the circumstance in question, namely, an SSPX Chapel's confessional is overtly and unambiguously independent of the Ordinary Jurisdiction of any Diocese, and that this fact is crystal clear to every Chapel attendee who approach such an SSPX minister.
Does Canon 844 Apply to the SSPX?
Angles proceeds to make a case for Canon 844 as a last-resort, yet definitive proof, that the Society is granted Supplied Jurisdiction by the 1983 Code.
He argues, in summary, that since this Canon grants Jurisdiction to any Schismatics so long as their Sacraments are Valid, and the other requirements are met; that, even conceding further that the SSPX were to be truly Schismatic, Canon 844 therefore supplies Jurisdiction to the Society of St. Pius X, even if you were to suppose that they are in Schism. This argument is in Part III of his Canonical Study.
However, this Canon certainly does not address groups such as the SSPX, but rather, Non-Catholic Churches. As the Code states clearly:
Can. 844, §2. Whenever necessity requires it or true spiritual advantage suggests it, and provided that danger of error or of indifferentism is avoided, the Christian faithful for whom it is physically or morally impossible to approach a Catholic minister are permitted to receive the sacraments of penance, Eucharist, and anointing of the sick from non-Catholic ministers in whose Churches these sacraments are valid.
Indeed, to be precise, the Society is a collective or coetus of Priests who exercise their priesthood independently of any Ordinary Jurisdiction, and under the penalties of Censures, particularly, Suspensio a Divinis, by reason of their illicit ordination, at the very least. According to the SSPX, they are not a Church, but rather a Society of Priests -- to be clear.
Though some, like Angles, suggest that this Canon can apply to any schismatic organization of Priests, the Canon Law Society of America's New Commentary on the 1983 Code, on the other hand, explains, with respect to the following paragraph §3:
No determination is made by the Canon concerning what churches are meant, that is, what churches may be considered by the Apostolic See to be "in the same condition" as the Eastern churches with regard to the Sacraments in question... One affirmative Roman judgement has been reached with regard to the Polish National Catholic Church in the United States and Canada, that this church is in the same condition as the Eastern churches, as just described, in regard to these Sacraments.... In effect, the canon, besides applying the Eastern norms to Catholics of the Latin Church and to Catholic ministers, extends the concession to other non-Eastern churches, but only after the Apostolic See has made the favorable judgement referred to above.
It thus appears evident that this Canon refers to those organizations the Apostolic See itself would consider at least equivalent, in their ecclesiastical reality, to the Eastern Orthodox; and thus any interpretation of this Canon needs to follow this understanding.
It suffices, in addressing the rest of Angles' argumentations, to point out that these points discredit Angle's interpretive methods for the 1983 Code. If we use the terms used in the Code of Canon Law beyond their appropriate meaning so as to conclude at least a positive probable doubt to obtain Jurisdiction, the Canonical justification proposed is none other than simply incoherent; for artificially extending the scope of the law establishes, ipso facto, a positive certainty that the law does not apply to the case in question. Assertions concerning a supposed probable doubt, in such cases, are put forward in vain only to confuse the reader.
In truth, the Society, its ministers, and the faithful attached to them, are all perfectly aware of the lack of any Jurisdiction and Canonical Mission from the Catholic Church; they simply believe this lack is "unjustly denied to them", and thus "ought to be given to them". Which, in any case, even if Jurisdiction were denied unjustly, the fact remains that their ministers lack Jurisdiction by reason of being de facto unincardinated into any Ordinary authority, and are thus exercising their Priesthood, simply speaking, independently of any regard to the Hierarchy of the Catholic Church, nay even opposed to its disposition toward them, both locally and with respect to the Supreme Legislator of the 1983 Code of Canon Law, the Roman Pontiff.



Comments