top of page

Msgr. Lefebvre's teaching on Supplied Jurisdiction

Oct 22
5 min read

Updated: Nov 14

It may surprise many to learn of the following statements of Archbishop Lefebvre, founder of the Society of St. Pius X. Indeed, the Society's entire reason for being, so it is claimed, is especially to safeguard the traditional Catholic doctrine of the Church.

The founder, pressed by the circumstances he and the many Catholics who followed behind him after the Episcopal Consecrations performed by him on June 30th of 1988 found themselves in, inevitably had to face the question of Jurisdiction when lacking a Canonical Mission from the Catholic Church, from the Roman Pontiff.

In order to justify an Episcopal ministry lacking all Jurisdiction or delegation of authority from the Roman Pontiff, Lefebvre found a solution which directly contradicts the teaching of the Catholic Church. His innovation concerns the idea of a Jurisdiction transmitted de facto, as it were triggered by, the request of the faithful, independent of a conferral of Jurisdiction from the Roman Pontiff; which establishes the individuals who make the request as personal subjects of the Bishop in question.

On the contrary, the Catholic Church teaches infallibly that no Jurisdiction or Mission for the salvation of souls can exist apart from a commission from the Hierarchy itself, at the top of which stands the Roman Pontiff, the Vicar of Christ. The Council of Trent says:

CANON VII.–If any one saith,...that those who have neither been rightly ordained, nor sent, by ecclesiastical and canonical authority, but come from elsewhere, are lawful ministers of the word and of the sacraments; let him be anathema. (Trent, Session 23, Ch. IV, Canon VII)

More than this, Msgr. Lefebvre specified with as much precision as he could, that he meant that this Jurisdiction is granted by the faithful themselves, and it is to the extent that the faithful grant their consent, that the Bishop in question has a Mission and Jurisdiction in their regard to fill all the proper duties of a Catholic Bishop.

On the contrary, this error was explicitly condemned as a heretical doctrine by Pope Pius VI's Auctorem Fidei, which says:

The proposition which states "that power has been given by God to the Church, that it might be communicated to the pastors who are its ministers for the salvation of souls"; if thus understood that the power of ecclesiastical ministry and of rule is derived from the COMMUNITY of the faithful to the pastors, [HERETICAL]. (Auctorem Fidei, Pius VI; Denzinger no. 1502.2)

Because it may be difficult to believe that Msgr. Lefebvre truly taught this, we include in full his correspondence dated Feb. 20th of 1991, in which he teaches these errors to the community of Campos in Brazil, explaining to them how they can justify the illicit Episcopal Consecrations to take place, and the illicit Ministry which that new bishop would undertake. Below is his correspondence in full:

20 February 1991 Dear Reverend Father Rifan, In addition to what I suggested in my letter to Bishop de Castro Mayer, I am sending you the attached note, in an attempt to harmonize the arrival of the new bishop and the creation of the Association of the Holy Curé of Ars, as well as the necessity of the apostolate being organized around the bishop. All authority has obedience as its corollary! The authority of the bishop will help in the unity and effectiveness of the apostolate. It is after reading your statutes that I thought it useful to write this note in order to avoid any conflict between the Association and the episcopal authority, but on the contrary to help them to work harmoniously for the good of souls and of the Catholic Church. Please convey my affectionate remembrance to the dear Bishop de Castro Mayer and assure him of our prayers. NOTE - Concerning the Jurisdiction of the New Bishop Precision seems to me very important in the solution of the problems of jurisdiction of the new bishop with respect to his priests and faithful. First of all, it must be noted that his situation is not exactly the same as that of Bishop de Castro Mayer. This latter is Bishop Emeritus of Campos, after having been its residential bishop. Hence, one could conclude that he kept, if not a juridical power, at least a moral power, which given the present circumstances, could justify a pastoral action with respect to his former priests and faithful. This is not the case with the new bishop, who has no other basis for jurisdiction than that which comes from the requests of the priests and the faithful to take care of their souls and those of their children, and who have asked him to accept the episcopacy so as to give them true Catholic priests and the grace of the Sacrament of Confirmation. Thus it is clear that the jurisdiction of the new bishop is not territorial but personal, as becomes also the jurisdiction of the priests. Inasmuch as the faithful request from the priests and the bishop the sacraments and the doctrine of the Faith, the priests and the bishop have the duty to watch over the good reception and good use of doctrine and the grace of the Sacrifice of the Mass and the Sacraments. The faithful cannot request the Sacraments and at the same time refuse the vigilant authority (et refuser l’autorité vigilante) of the priests and the bishop. In order to watch over the good order of the apostolate and its efficacy, the organization of the Society of the Holy Cure of Ars seems very appropriate and ought to reunite obligatorily all the priests who desire to continue the traditional apostolate. It would seem desirable that the bishop, once consecrated, be named president of the presbyteral council for life, in order that he might hold an authority, which is indispensable for the nomination of priests, for new foundations, for inter-parish activities, for the seminary and religious societies. Since the jurisdictional authority (L’autorité juridictionnelle) of the bishop does not come from a Roman nomination, but from the necessity of the salvation of souls, he will have to exercise it with a special delicacy and taking special account of his presbyteral council. Moreover, the faithful and priests must acknowledge the grace of having a pastor, successor of the Apostles, and guardian of Tradition of the deposit of the Faith, of the eucharistic Sacrifice, of the Catholic priesthood and of the grace of the Sacraments, and they must consequently facilitate the exercise of his authority by a generous obedience. Since the jurisdiction of the bishop is not territorial but personal and has as its source the duty of the faithful to save their souls, if a group of faithful in the diocese calls upon the bishop to have a priest, this group gives by this very fact, authority to the bishop [HERETICAL] (ce groupe donne par le fait même, pouvoir à l’évêque) to watch over the transmission of the Faith and of grace in this group, by the intermediary of the priest that he sent. Thus, so it seems to me, will be resolved in an order, which is in conformity to the spirit of the Church, the delicate problems which come from an episcopal consecration without the explicit mandate of Rome but with the implicit mandate of the Roman Church, Guardian of the Faith. The new bishop remains the ontological link with the Church [!], faithful to its Divine Spouse, Our Lord Jesus Christ. + Marcel Lefebvre February 20, 1991

It should be noted, however, that Bernard Tissier de Mallerais adjusted this theory somewhat, with the idea that this Jurisdiction is derived, more precisely, from the "Mystical Body of Christ", and from "Christ as Head of the Church".


 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page