Tissier de Mallerais' teaching on Supplied Jurisdiction
Updated: 2 days ago
From natural common sense, it seems to many that owing to the dire situation in which the Church finds itself today, the ordinary structure and hierarchy of the Church is more harmful than beneficial to the salvation of souls, and that the ordinary exigencies of such Hierarchic structure may be suspended during this state of necessity; the summary definition of state of necessity as understood by the Society could be presented in the words of Don Davide Pagliarani:
It is sad to acknowledge, but it is a fact that, in an ordinary parish, the faithful no longer find the means necessary to ensure their eternal salvation. Missing, in particular, are both the integral preaching of Catholic truth and morality, and the worthy administration of the sacraments as the Church has always done. (LifeSiteNews, Feb. 5th, 2026)
It is in view of such a state that the Society of St. Pius X believes that an explicit Mission and conferral of Jurisdiction from the Church would not be necessary to exercise a Pastoral Ministry for the faithful.
This may be understood as the basic framing of the justification proposed by the SSPX in their various articles and podcasts available on www.sspx.org and their Youtube Channel.
In favor of such a proposition, the arguments proposed by the late SSPX bishop Tissier de Mallerais, in his article explaining the Society’s teaching from a doctrinal point of view concerning Supplied Jurisdiction for Pastoral Ministry, are the most consistent with the concrete reality of how the SSPX understands itself and functions day-to-day.
As showcased in the First Part of the SSPX's YouTube Documentary titled “Traditio - A Work of Faith”, bishop Tissier de Mallerais was one of the most intimate collaborators of Msgr. Lefebvre, and is considered to be the most faithful to his spirit, and as it were, something of a guiding light for the SSPX after the death of Lefebvre.
In his article, de Mallerais makes the claim that “traditional Priests” receive a Supplied Jurisdiction in the proper sense of Pastoral duty and office, directly from Christ, so as to respond to the sacramental needs of the faithful during times of crisis. He defines Supplied Jurisdiction thus:
This is the case where the Church directly confers jurisdiction on a priest without going through the different degrees of the hierarchy. It is the Mystical Body of Our Lord, Our Lord Himself as Head of His Church, which gives jurisdiction to priests in some particular cases… In the present situation of crisis, it is obvious that your priests cannot receive from their superiors in the church, that is to say from the diocesan bishops and from the Pope, a flock, because that flock is refused to them. This authority over a flock must, therefore, be given to them in another manner: that is, by substitute or supplied jurisdiction… It is the supplying for the absence of jurisdiction in a priest or a bishop: "Ecclesia supplet." It is neither the pope nor the diocesan hierarchy which gives their flock to the traditional clergy, but the Church, and Our Lord Jesus Christ as Head of His Mystical Body. It is they who sanction and declare this case of necessity for the faithful.[1]
He explains in this article how the Jurisdiction supplied by Christ to independent traditional Priests apart from any delegation from the Hierarchy through “His Mystical Body” (referred to simply as “the Church”), grants these Priests the power and authority of a true Pastor, save limited to this or that particular person “in need of help” – and yet that a true Jurisdiction exists, of the same nature as a Diocesan Pastor sent and appointed by the Catholic Church, albeit with one difference:
It is a personal and not a territorial jurisdiction…Your [traditional] priests have jurisdiction over your persons and not over a territory. Traditional priests have jurisdiction over each one of their faithful who come to their chapel or traditional church or traditional convent or priory, and they do not have jurisdiction over a determined territory as for example the territory of a [diocesan] parish.
Again, as he already stated, due to the lack of Jurisdiction or delegation from the Pope and the visible Hierarchy of the Church, their Priests receive this Pastoral Jurisdiction from “...the Mystical Body of Our Lord, Our Lord Himself as Head of His Church”.
He says further…
It is exactly inasmuch as you accept the principle of supplied authority of the priests and of its exercise over yourselves, that their authority over the flock will be extended, efficacious, genuine, continuous and broad.
As he explains in the subheading of “The general extent of supplied jurisdiction”, this Pastoral Jurisdiction gives them indeed a carte blanche authority to dispense all the Sacraments…:
It is not only present for confessions, but also for the entire priestly ministry. There is no reason to limit it to confessions alone.
By these statements, it seems evident that de Mallerais posits that there exists a Mystical, invisible polity over and above the visible Church, which is governed immediately by Christ as Head, during this time of crisis; and that it is Christ Himself who, “without involving the hierarchy”, supplies Jurisdiction to traditional Priests acting independently of the ordinary delegation of the Supreme Pastoral Jurisdiction flowing from the Roman Pontiff. This he referred to above as the Mystical Body of Christ, “Our Lord Himself as Head of His Church” which supplies Jurisdiction, it is this “Mystical Body”, which he refers to when he speaks of “the Church”, which:
...opens wide the doors of her mercy and gives jurisdiction to any priest.
As he already said, “without involving the hierarchy”.
In all honesty, it must be admitted that this understanding of a Pastoral Jurisdiction independent of the Catholic Church’s visible Hierarchy is the only possible justification to explain the concrete, independent Pastoral activity of the SSPX in practice – in reality.
Indeed, this seems to be the only way to explain the reality of the unrestricted, carte blanche application of the concept of “Supplied Jurisdiction in case of necessity” as employed by the SSPX – a concept in Canon Law which has always been understood in the Church as a concession precisely by the Church, and thus ultimately by the Pope, destined for case-by-case situations, governed by the law itself in consonance with the Divine Constitution of the Church.
This understanding is clearly manifest at https://fsspx.today/, which names the head Priest as the Pastor. Whether designated as Chapels or Churches, the Priest in charge is designated precisely as the Pastor of the Church. Some of their communities are referred to explicitly as Parishes; and among the information and announcements for every location, there is a designated page labeled the “Pastor’s Corner” wherein the Priest in charge gives his reflections for the season or Sunday.
We find this to be perfectly consistent with the understanding of Archbishop Lefebvre, quoted in Bp. Tissier de Mallerais’ article:
Your chapels are your parishes, consider your priories and your chapels as your parishes, that is where you are. Do not return to your former parishes, which have fallen into the hands of the modernists.
Utterly astounded by this teaching of the Society, we begin citing the grave words of Pope Leo XIII:
Those who arbitrarily conjure up and picture to themselves a hidden and invisible Church are in grievous and pernicious error…The union consequently of visible and invisible elements because it harmonizes with the natural order and by God’s will belongs to the very essence of the Church, must necessarily remain so long as the Church itself shall endure. Wherefore Chrysostom writes: “Secede not from the Church: for nothing is stronger than the Church. Thy hope is the Church; thy salvation is the Church; thy refuge is the Church. It is higher than the heavens and wider than the earth. It never grows old, but is ever full of vigour. Wherefore Holy Writ pointing to its strength and stability calls it a mountain” (Hom. De capto Eutropio, n. 6). He who seeks the truth must be guided by these fundamental principles.[2]
Because the precise departure from Catholic teaching may not be evident, we would like to present why we have found this theological principle underlying the autonomous ministry of the Society to be contrary to the Catholic Faith.
In the first place, Fr. Francis De Zulueta, S.J. summarizes the central objection from common sense that strikes us:
Since men need to know the genuine envoy of Christ from the spurious one, the fact of this transmission of authority must be a visible, tangible fact, capable of being investigated and tested. Hence the process by which the alleged minister of today has personally had the right which he claims passed on to him must be susceptible of intelligible proof from appreciable facts. The right to guide my precious, immortal soul amid the deceitful shoals of this life, claimed by Father So-and-so, must rest not merely on the fact that he is arrayed clerically, functions as a clergyman in some ecclesiastical-looking building, or in Hyde Park, or that he asserts, or takes for granted, or inwardly feels that he is sent by Christ.[3] His inward “spiritual experience” of a call and of a mission, if not a delusion, may possibly justify him in conscience for claiming my submission; but, being beyond my ken, it will not suffice my conscience for yielding it.
Contrary to the proposition of bishop de Mallerais, we consider from principles of Faith that it is precisely by the Divine Institution of Christ that the ministry of the Sacraments was committed to the perduring Hierarchy of the Catholic Church alone, in dependence on the Universal Jurisdiction of the Pope. From the Seraphic Doctor St. Bonaventure:
The Lord Jesus Christ, creator of all things and governor of His Holy Church, ascending into Heaven, committed the government and expansion of it to the Apostles, and principally to the Apostle Peter, to whom was said the third time concerning the totality of the flock of the faithful: Feed my sheep (John 21:17).[4]
Concerning the Power of the Keys, with respect to Jurisdiction, the Seraphic Doctor minutely establishes the point at hand:
Whomsever in the Church holds power [aliquis habeat potestatem], this he has [ultimately] from Christ, who in turn committed this power to the Apostles, and in a special manner to Peter…a twofold power hence is committed to Peter, to bind and loose in the penitentiary forum, and to bind and loose in the judiciary forum; the first arises from the power of Order, the second from the power of Prelature…As to the [exercise of the] first power, in that it has been committed to Peter, as Priests, this power descends to all from him.[5]
Indeed, together with the Angelic Doctor St. Thomas, Bonaventure delineates the wisdom of Christ in this regard:
Just as we see in all things whether rational, natural, or among heavenly things, to wit, that there is to be found concord and decorum, so also it is that there should be order in this regard; this is how the matter is understood concerning spiritual power within the Church, for which it is read “she is terrible, as an army set in battle array (Cant. 6:9). Because, therefore, it belongs to right order that there exist prelature and subjection, and prelature according to ascent and descent, not equality…Accordingly then, in consonance with right order, it was necessary that in the Church there be one supreme and first Prelate, in whom there be found the sum of all Ecclesiastical prelature…again, because from the descent of one there is found consequently multiplicity, and from this, diminution of power;...as such one indeed finds power in the Parochial Priest, who is given the immediate care of the people, yet in this, his Jurisdiction is delimited to a little determined portion according to right order, and that portion is thus known to be his lot. Now because it is not permitted that any Priest cast his hand in another’s lot, hence it is that one has no power to absolve the subjects committed to another.[6]
As St. Thomas Aquinas likewise teaches:
Those things that must work on particulars do not apply to all things in the same way. Therefore, just as after the general precepts of medicine, doctors must be summoned, by whom the universal precepts of medicine may be adapted to the individual sick men as needed, so also, in any leadership apart from him who hands down all precepts of law, it is necessary to have certain ones who adapt things to individuals as needed. And because of this also in the heavenly hierarchy under the powers, who are indistinctly at the head, are set the principalities, who are distributed to individual provinces. And under these are the angels who are assigned to the care of individual people, as is clear from what was said in Book 2, Distinction 20. And so it ought also to be this way in the hierarchy of the Church Militant, that some one person should have eminence indistinctly over all, and beneath him would be others who would receive particular power over certain people. And because the use of the keys requires a certain power of eminence by which the person for whom the use of the keys is employed becomes the proper matter of that act, therefore the person who has indistinct power over all can use the keys on anyone. But those who receive particular powers beneath this person cannot use the keys on everyone.[7]
Again, St. Thomas:
Spiritual judgment should be more ordered than temporal. But in temporal judgment, not just any judge can judge any given person. Therefore, since the use of the keys is a kind of judgment, a priest cannot use his own power of keys over simply anyone whatsoever.[8]
St. Bonaventure further notes, in consonance with these principles, that this power to judge must be tangibly committed to him by a superior:
Such a judgement [of binding and loosing] cannot exist without a certain jurisdiction over he who is judged, because no man can pronounce judgement upon another, unless he be placed as judge over another, namely, by him who is able to assign this [power].[9]
Indeed, Bonaventure notes that not only is any Jurisdiction dependent on the mediation of the Roman Pontiff, but further, no inferior can licitly exercise any Spiritual Power whatsoever contrary to his prohibition:
Because Jurisdiction descends in an orderly manner from the superior to the inferior, such that the plenitude of it resides in the Supreme Pontiff; so it is that the Pope can take it away, and the power that follows from it…[as such], the execution of any spiritual power must be carried out in consonance with his regimen; and thus, if the Pope were to prohibit such execution, such power cannot licitly be carried forth into act.[10]
In other words, from St. Thomas:
The first cause has more influence on what is caused by a second cause than even the second cause itself does, as is said in the Book of Causes…So too the pope’s power relates to every spiritual power in the Church, since it is by the pope that the different degrees of dignities in the Church are both arranged and ordered. Hence his power is like the Church’s foundation, as is clear (Matt 16:18).[11]
Again from St. Thomas:
Although the power of binding and loosing was given to all apostles in common, nevertheless so that in this power a certain order might be signified, it was first given to Peter alone, so that it might be shown that from him this power should descend to the others, which is also why it was said to him in the singular, strengthen your brothers (Luke 22:32), and feed my sheep (Jn 21:17), that is, in my place.[12]
More explicitly, St. Bonaventure affirms of the Roman Pontiff that he is:
The Vicar of Christ, the fount and origin, the rule of all Ecclesiastical powers, from whom as from the supreme power is derived the ordered power even to the lowest Ecclesiastical member, as is necessary to the preeminent dignity to be found within the Ecclesiastical hierarchy.”[13] … “The Apostolic See holds immediate care of the Church, and from it do all other Pastors in the Church, major as well as minor, receive authority for governance, mediately as well as immediately, and from this See all Canonical legislation emanates.[14]
Behold our objection: if all Jurisdiction, that is of any sort, depends on the Roman Pontiff insofar as the fontal plenitude of Jurisdiction is committed to him, it follows that any Jurisdiction supplied a Jure depends on his moral mediation, whereby any appeal to an interpretation of law must not and cannot stand contrary to a prohibitive manifestation of his will for such acts, dependent as they are, by nature of the matter, on the presumption of a supplied authority ultimately dependent on him.[15]
But to return to the matter at hand, St. Bonaventure continues to make the distinction, in application to the Sacraments which can be performed validly contrary to the will of the Pope, that these are accomplished in fact yet illicitly:
However, because [certain acts] do not depend on the Pope ‘secundum rem’, they are accomplished [validly] de facto, as with other Sacraments of this kind.[16]
However, with respect to those which require Jurisdiction for validity, he makes the following distinction, making clear that no judicial act is valid which lacks the Jurisdiction descending from the Roman Pontiff:
Jurisdiction is likened to a motive power for the exercise of the keys, just as a hand is; such that if the hand fails, to whatsoever the keys are applied, even though the keys be present, he opens nothing; as such if Jurisdiction is taken away, the execution of the keys ceases.[17]
In confirmation of this, we found that Cardinal Giovanni Soglia’s Institutiones Juris Publici et Privati. (1853) provides a rather succinct summary of the common understanding of this doctrine as taught by these two princes of Scholasticism:
The power of jurisdiction is customarily defined as “the legitimate assignment of subjects,” or, as others prefer, “legitimate deputation to declare the law or to command.” In that hierarchy, assignment of subjects is made by law, or by a man [a jure, vel ab homine]; by law either divine or ecclesiastical. Of divine law there are two grades of jurisdiction, the Supreme Pontificate, and the Episcopate; of ecclesiastical law are all other ecclesiastical offices [munera], to which jurisdiction in the external forum is attached; but the assignment of subjects is made by a man, when somebody delegates his own jurisdiction to another. ... Returning from this digression, this power [of jurisdiction] is conferred by the assignment of subjects, or by legitimate deputation to exercise a spiritual duty [munus], without which [deputation] acts of jurisdiction are null, both in the internal and the external fora. On this matter the Council of Trent defined, “If anyone shall say ... those are legitimate ministers of the word and the Sacraments, who by ecclesiastical and canonical power are neither rightly ordained, nor sent, let him be anathema” (sess. 23, can. 7). Thus two things are required: both order, and legitimate mission, of which the first is obtained by holy Ordination, the other by the legitimate assignment of subjects. Indeed, that this pertains to the internal forum, the same Synod decreed: "Therefore, since the nature and essence of a judgment require that the sentence be imposed only on subjects, there has always been the conviction in the Church of God, and this Synod confirms it as most true, that this absolution which the priest pronounces upon one over whom he has no ordinary or delegated jurisdiction has no value." (Council of Trent, sess. 14, chap. 7 [Denz. 903]).[18]
This last teaching of the Council of Trent, “this Synod confirms it as most true, that this absolution…over whom he has no Ordinary or Delegated Jurisdiction has no value”, is what we identified to be the foundation of the unanimous teaching of the Theologians after the Council of Trent, who all seem to teach that Jurisdiction and Mission cannot be had in any way except through the mediation of the Hierarchy in dependence on the Pope; and hence, when that Hierarchy denies it, the Priest cannot exercise it in any sense, and this by Divine Institution as taught by St. Bonaventure, St. Thomas, together with the Magisterium.
In agreement with the above-cited passages, Cdl. Lorenzo Brancati (†1693) of the Friars Minor Conventual, further presses the point that all Jurisdiction necessarily comes from the delegation of the Church, insofar as it is a visible Hierarchy, ultimately dependent on the mediation of the Pope, and never from Christ directly:
Now jurisdiction in the Church exists through the mediation of the Pope, as was proven in the preceding disputation on the Power of the Keys; but in the Pope it exists immediately from God. Therefore delegates [by supplied jurisdiction] even in the case of death are delegated immediately by the Church, not by God directly. Otherwise the aforesaid priests in those acts would not depend on the Pope; but this is evidently false.[19]
Indeed, he says it is another Catholic principle of Sacramental Theology that…:
...whatsoever God gives immediately and by Himself,... He gives at the moment of Ordination; therefore, if jurisdictional power is not possessed at that moment [from God], it is therefore never possessed immediately from God.[20]
The venerable Francisco Suarez, S.J., after distinguishing the manner in which the Apostles received Jurisdiction immediately from Christ, the reasons for this, and the cessation of such power at their death, teaches the following concerning Jurisdiction in all those who followed after Our Lord’s Ascension:
The aforesaid Jurisdiction as given immediately by Christ was granted only to the Apostles — Indeed I say fourthly: Christ the Lord, by Himself and immediately, never conferred Jurisdiction upon anyone else. This assertion is proved by negative authority, which in matters supernatural and of the Faith is sufficient. Thus, in the Gospel we do not read that He conferred it upon anyone else apart from the Apostles. For although He also chose the seventy disciples, He did so in a manner very different from the Apostles, and nowhere did He confer such power upon them, as Bellarmine well explains in Book I, De Clericis, chapter 14. Nor can it be established from the tradition of the Church that Christ, either before or after His Ascension, gave or gives this power immediately to anyone.[21]
We gather all this to mean that it is God Himself who delineated by Divine Law how Jurisdiction is to be received by any Priest whatsoever in the Catholic Church, namely, through the authority bestowed on the Catholic Hierarchy ultimately dependent on the mediation of the Supreme, Visible Head of the Church: the Pope. As the celebrated Cardinal Cajetan taught:
…the manner in which the Church, through Peter, receives the keys even to the consummation of the age, is most sweetly disposed by the divine wisdom: for as the universal Church is distributed into head and members, so is she distributed in the sweet reception of the keys, so that in the head indeed she receives by succession, but in the members by participation. For in the head she has the keys of the kingdom of heaven according to the acts adequate to the keys; but in the members, that is, in the partial churches, she has the keys according to the acts of order and of partial jurisdiction.[22]
In other words: through the Visible and Apostolic conferral of authority and also of Mission, essential de jure Divino to the nature of the Catholic Church founded by Christ, exactly as the Catechism of the Council Trent teaches:
That all, therefore, may know the true Catholic Church, the Fathers, guided by the Spirit of God, added to the Creed the word “APOSTOLIC;” for the Holy Ghost, who presides over the Church, governs her by no other means than through Apostolic men [that is, who are sent; i.e. Apostles][23]
The same was intimated by Pope Innocent III’s Cum Ex Injuncto in opposition to clerics who presumed to have any form of Jurisdiction immediately from God:
If anyone perhaps responds shrewdly to this that such men are sent invisibly by God, even if they are not visibly sent by man, since an invisible mission is much more worthy than a visible one, and a divine mission is far better than a human one (from which John the Baptist is not said to be sent by man, but by God, just as the Evangelist witnesses: “There was a man sent from God, whose name was John”, John 1:6), it can and should certainly be answered reasonably that when that inner mission is hidden, it does not suffice for anyone to assert so boldly that he is sent by God, since any heretic may profess this: but it is necessary that he proves that invisible mission by the working of miracles or by special testimony of the Scriptures… Therefore he who says that he is sent by God should not be believed, since he has not been sent by man, unless he offers special testimony from Scripture for his person, or he shows an obvious miracle.[24]
Cardinal Billot S.J.’s De Ecclesiae Sacramentis Thesis XVI, admirably summarizes what we have thus far presented in the following words:
In the Catholic Church alone resides, by the institution of Christ, the supreme authority to dispense the sacraments; hence, in the absence of a commission received from her, the administration of the sacraments is illicit and sacrilegious. [25]
Perhaps for good reason St. Jerome stressed so boldly the following sentence!...
Whosoever shall have eaten the lamb outside this house, namely, the house founded upon the Chair of Peter, is profane![26]
Dear friends, does not the judgement of Theologians and of the Church, along with the entirety of Catholic Tradition confirm our objection?
How could any Priest presume to possess the authority “to shepherd the faithful”, save those who have been established by the will of the territorial Ordinaries appointed or confirmed by the Pope in union with him, as we intimate from Vatican Council I? We cite the words of the Council here…
He sent the Apostles whom He had chosen to Himself from the world, as He Himself had been sent by the Father; so He willed that there should ever be pastors and teachers in His Church to the end of the world. And in order that the Episcopate also might be one and undivided, and that by means of a closely united priesthood the multitude of the faithful might be kept secure in the oneness of faith and communion, He set Blessed Peter over the rest of the Apostles, and fixed in him the abiding principle of this twofold unity and its visible foundation, in the strength of which the everlasting temple should arise, and the Church in the firmness of that faith should lift her majestic front to heaven. …If anyone, therefore, shall say that Blessed Peter the Apostle was not appointed the Prince of all the Apostles and the visible Head of the whole Church Militant; or that the same, directly and immediately, received from the same, Our Lord Jesus Christ, a primacy of honor only, and not of true and proper jurisdiction; let him be anathema.[27]
Although the official apologetics we found on the SSPX websites bring forth many complex arguments to justify the wholly autonomous existence of the Society from a standpoint of Canonical Jurisprudence, [28] the glaring contradiction in their argumentation appears before us precisely in the concrete application of their theses; for they openly confer the sacraments as Pastors of souls receiving authority over persons from Christ directly, as bp. Tissier de Mallerais clarified – and this, because the Hierarchy denies them Jurisdiction and Mission for the Sacraments.
Indeed, attempts, pro casu, for the supplying of authority must ultimately fall in consonance with the will of the supreme legislator, that is to say, the Roman Pontiff, from whom Supplied Jurisdiction is derived, [29] such that in the event of an explicit prohibition of the Pope in the exercise of a Sacramental Act requiring either Mission or Jurisdiction, the execution of the Act is either null and void, as in the case of Absolution or Marriage, or it is simply valid yet illicit, as we have already gathered: “the execution of any spiritual power must be carried out in consonance with his regimen; and thus, if the Pope were to prohibit such execution, such power cannot licitly be carried forth into act.” [30]
Hence, as de Mallerais argued above, if it is not possible to receive such authority from the Pope, because he refuses to give it, it “must be given” in some other manner. According to bishop Tissier de Mallerais, this is by a direct conferral from Christ as Head of the Church. No other explanation seems possible according to reason. And yet this very thing appears contrary to the points of Dogma we are here presenting.
We do not therefore understand how the arguments in favor of the Society excuse them from a true saltem de facto Schism from the Catholic Church, in view of this willful Sacramental independence, together with their claims to a true Mission and Pastoral Jurisdiction independent of the Catholic Church [31]– indeed a Jurisdiction not only parallel but exclusive.
To our limited knowledge, neither the principles of Canonical Jurisprudence nor Canons of either the 1917 Code or 1983 Code seem to suggest that the Church, much less the person of the Roman Pontiff, has the ability to alienate the exclusive rights of the Papal Primacy and the Divine constitution of the Church by a mere human judgement or interpretation…:
In all essential points the constitution of the Church is based on divine directives, and therefore it is not subject to human arbitrariness.[32]
It seems only consonant with right reason to expect that this dispensation, or if you will, suspension, of Divine Law apparently suggested by the Society of St. Pius X would necessarily need to be made clear to us by God Himself by some tangible testimony – otherwise there would be nothing that could provide a moral certainty that the Sacraments conferred by them are not gravely sacrilegious by reason of this independence from the Catholic Church.[33]
In summary, it does not seem that any interpretation of Canon Law can undermine or supply Jurisdiction contrary to the Divinely instituted nature of the Catholic Church, as Francisco Suarez, S.J. intimates, that no inferior is able to bind or legislate “against the law and will of a superior” [34]; suggesting that not even the Church is able to offer any assurance in Canon Law that Jurisdiction or Mission can exist apart from the divinely established order proper to the Church’s Hierarchic and visible nature.
In truth, on this point, we cannot do otherwise than say together with the Theologian Fr. George Agius, in his work “Tradition and the Church” (1928):
We do not contend that Christ could not have given His Church another system, than that which He was pleased to choose. We simply state, that, since He established a certain form of government, that form must remain. It is essential for the life of the Church. If changed, the whole Church is changed. Our task, therefore, is to show that in the institution of the Apostolate, Christ intended that there should be an ever living body of men to continue His work to the end of time. In other words, in choosing the twelve Apostles as the first propagators of His Divine Religion, He also established a perpetual apostolic succession with the authority of teaching In His name. To be plain, He intended that the Apostles should appoint and ordain others to succeed them in their office, who in turn would appoint and ordain others to preach the Gospel, and rule the Church, and so to the end of the world. The government of the Church, after the death of the Apostles, is to be homogeneous with the original one. Its progress will be perfectly identical with that of the Apostolic government. No substantial change or modification of government will be suffered in the future; no different economy, no differently established order.[35]
Again, with the Council of Trent, cited by Cdl. Soglia above, we rather wish to confirm, confess, and join in saying with the infallible judgement of the Church:
Sess. 23; CANON VII .– If any one saith, that those who have not been ordained nor sent according to due ecclesiastical and canonical authority [ab Ecclesiastica & Canonica postestate rite ordinati, nec missi], but come from elsewhere, are lawful ministers of the word and of the sacraments; let him be anathema![36]
[1] It is important to note here that there is a glaring contradiction at play, which will be made clear by what follows. The Church is not and cannot function as an invisible polity in contradiction with the Hierarchy. This is a fundamental error that may be difficult to notice at first glance, but is crucial to the matter at hand.
[2] Pope Leo XIII, Enyc. Satis Cognitum.
[3] Francis De Zulueta, S.J., Letters on Christian Doctrine, Vol III, p. 58-59 (1915)
[4] St. Bonaventure, Opuscula; Quare Fratres Minorum Praedicent; Expos. Super Reg. Fra. Min. Cap. IX.
[5] St. Bonaventure, Comm. in IV Sent. d. 18, p.2, a.1, q3.
[6] St. Bonaventure Comm. in IV Sent. d. 19, a. 3, q.1; the same is taught nearly verbatim by St. Thomas in the same place, articles 1-3.
[7] St. Thomas, Comm. in IV Sent. d. 19, a. 3, q. 3.
[8] St. Thomas, Comm. in IV Sent. d. 19, a. 3, q. 1.
[9] St. Bonaventure Comm in IV Sent. d. 19, a. 2, q. 2.
[10] St. Bonaventure Comm. in IV Sent. d. 25, a. 1, q. 2, et ad 3.
[11] St. Thomas, Expositio Super Textum Magistri, Comm. in II Sent., d. 44, q. 2.
[12] St. Thomas, Comm. in IV Sent. d. 24, a. 2, Resp. qc. 3
[13] St. Bonaventure, Breviloquium, Pars VI, Cap. X
[14] St. Bonaventure, Determin. Quaest. Circa Regula S. Francisci.
[15] That is, by force of a law dependent on the Roman Pontiff’s intent to confer Jurisdiction by that law. This is the point, in principle, which frustrates the interpretations of Canon 19 by Fr. Peter Scott, as well as those of Fr. Ramon Angles, found on SSPX.org.
[16] Ibid. ut supra., immediately following.
[17] St. Bonaventure Comm. in IV Sent., d.19, a.2, q.2
[18] Vol II, Liber Primus, Cap. I, p. 6-8
[19] Cdl. Lorenzo Brancati, Comm. in IV Sent. Disp. XIX, Art. IX.
[20] ibid.
[21] Francisco Suarez, S.J., Opera Omnia T. V, De Legibus, Liber IV, Cap. III. Suarez here excludes the Roman Pontiff, of course, as he details within this same Treatise.
[22] Cardinal Tommaso de Vio Cajetan, De Divina Institutione Pontificatus Romani Pontificis, Caput VI.
[23] Roman Catechism, On the Marks of the Church.
[24] Decretalium Gregorii IX, Lib. V., Titulus VII., Cap. XII. https://archive.org/details/gri_33125008736171/page/1178/mode/2up
[25] Louis Cardinal Billot, S.J., De Ecclesiae Sacramentis, Tomus Prior, Thesis XVI (5th ed., Rome, 1914), p. 176.
[26] Epistles of St. Jerome, n. 15, 22, 355.
[27] Vatican I, Pastor Aeternus, Ch. 1
[28] An argument is proposed reliant on the analogy of law to be applied in cases of situations not foreseen in the code of law per CIC 1917 Can. 20, and the CIC 1989 Can. 19, by Fr. Peter Scott; yet again this analogy falls short not only in view of the Dogmatic premises of Jurisdiction presented by us here, but also in view of the perennial praxis of the Church concerning the existence of acephalous Clergy whether presbyters or bishops. Our research into the ultimate reality of SSPX clergy quatenus clerici acephali make it clear that an analogia legis that justifies an indefinitely de facto acephalous clergy seems incoherent. We refer our studious readers to those sources cited in the old Corpus Juris Canonicis, Distinctions 70-72 in the Decr. Gratiani., of which we cite the following: Conc. Nic. I, Can. 16; Conc. Sard., Can. 18-19; Conc. Carth.; Conc. Chalc., Can. 6, 20; St. Greg. I., Hom. 26 in Evang.; Conc. Nic. II., Can. 10, 15; Conc. Placent. sub Urban., II.; Conc. Triden. Sess. 23, Can. 7. By these Decrees of the Councils we can infer that the Church never intends the subsistence of independent Clerical associations who administer the Sacraments apart from and in opposition to the Hierarchy of the Catholic Church.
[29] See quote attached to note no. 13 above.
[30] St. Bonaventure, ut supra. The context, interestingly, within which St. Bonaventure establishes this principle is the illicit Consecration of Bishops vis-à-vis a prohibition to Consecrate by the Pope.
[31] Some apologists for the Society suggest that they received a Canonical Mission from the Church at some point in the past, and hence, because (as they argue) any censures are invalid by reason of injustice, they still retain this original Canonical Mission. But the claim to Canonical Mission in their case flies contrary to the express denial of any such Mission on the part of the Holy See and also to the record presented by the Society here: https://sspx.org/en/legal-existence-sspx-30977 – indeed, from the Society’s original subordination to the local Diocese of Fribourg, such Mission, if for the sake of argument it included anything beyond the formation of candidates to the Priesthood, would nevertheless only ever be limited to that Diocese in any case, as the commendation from the S.C. of the Clergy did not grant any Mission for the administration of the Sacraments, whereby their exercise of Sacramental Acts requiring Mission or Jurisdiction extending beyond this territory would necessarily lack such hypothetically extant Status. We therefore fail to comprehend this line of argumentation, as the Society functions as a global Apostolate spanning the Jurisdictions of many countries. Unless we are missing something, we would say bishop de Mallerais provides the most coherent argumentation in their favor, the presumption of a practical suspension of Catholic principles notwithstanding.
[32] Bl. Pius IX, Mirabilis Illa Constantia Denzinger-Heinrich n. 3114-3117
[33] We cite also the grave words of St. Cyprian of Carthage: «Since there is one Church from Christ throughout the whole world, divided into many members, and likewise one episcopate, spread abroad in the harmonious multitude of many bishops, he, after the ordinance of God, after the compact and everywhere united unity of the Catholic Church, attempts to make a human church, and sends his own new apostles through many cities, that he may establish certain novel foundations of his own institution. And although bishops have long since been ordained throughout all the provinces and in each individual city—men advanced in years, sound in faith, proved under pressure, proscribed in persecution—he dares to create other pseudo-bishops over them, as though he could either traverse the whole world by the obstinacy of his new undertaking, or tear apart the structure of the ecclesiastical body by sowing his discord; not knowing that schismatics always blaze for a time at their beginnings, but are unable to attain growth; nor can they increase what they have unlawfully begun, but quickly fail together with their perverse rivalry. He, therefore, who observes neither the unity of the Spirit nor the bond of peace, and separates himself from the bond of the Church and from the college of priests, can possess neither the power nor the honor of a bishop, since he has been unwilling to maintain either the unity or the peace of the episcopate.». Decretum Gratiani, Secunda Pars, Causa VII, Q. 1, Cap. VI. cf. Collectio Canonum Anselmi Lib. 6., Cap. 57.
[34] Suarez, S.J., Opera Omnia Tom. V, De Legibus, Lib. 1, Ch. IX
[35] Agius, Tradition and the Church, p. 39-43
[36] See citation no. 18.



Comments