Fr Peter Scott on Supplied Jurisdiction
Updated: 6 days ago
Fr. Peter Scott presents an argument from Canon Law based on Canon 19, which says:
Canon 19. If a custom or an express prescript of universal or particular law is lacking in a certain matter, a case, unless it is penal, must be resolved in light of laws issued in similar matters, general principles of law applied with canonical equity, the jurisprudence and practice of the Roman Curia, and the common and constant opinion of learned persons.
This Canon allows an interpreter of the Code such as an Ecclesiastical judge to apply analogies of Law from the principles of Jurisprudence, previously ratified law, and other sources, to fill any potential gaps in the Code with respect to a particular case, in order to properly execute Justice. This allows particular Ecclesiastical authorities to apply Justice adequately and in harmony with right reason without adhering strictly to the letter of the Law, which in this case, is altogether lacking. As Wernz & Vidal explains:
No Code has been drawn up so carefully that everything that can occur in the juridical life of a society has been expressly foreseen. Moreover, as time passes, new juridical relations arise for which positive law must provide a norm, and which could not have been foreseen by the legislator. Nevertheless, every particular case arising in juridical life must, when recourse is made to judges, be decided by them according to juridical principles rather than arbitrarily. The function of supplementary law is to supply a binding juridical norm where the Code lacks one, rather than to provide assistance for the doctrinal interpretation of the Code, although it can also serve this purpose [per accidens] to the highest degree. (Jus Canonicum, Tome I, no. 179)
From these basic definitions, it is evident that Canon 19 is a Canonical provision for the application or enforcement of Justice, on the part of a person in authority exercising that authority to adjudicate a particular case. It should go without saying that this Canon is not meant to allow private individuals to supply laws contrary to the will of the Legislator, in order to supply for themselves Jurisdiction in general.
Fr. Scott uses this Canon to make the argument that based on the Church's previous and current Canonical concessions for Supplied Jurisdiction, a Priest of the Society can presume a supplied delegation from the Roman Pontiff, the Legislator of the Code, to dispense the Sacraments on the grounds of necessity, indeed, so long as need is present. He expands this argument briefly in his introduction to Tissier de Mallerais' theological argument.
Scott first applies for the SSPX clergy "laws promulgated for similar circumstances", and he lists the Canons for Common Error (Canon 144) and the Danger of Death (Canon 976 and 1357). It is not clear which analogy he is drawing with respect to Common Error, but from this he gathers that the Legislator intends to supply Jurisdiction at least in this case, for the good of the faithful, and thus would intend to do so as well in general, if similar cases should come about (Click here for a detailed review of Common Error and Canon 144). With respect to the Danger of Death, the only analogy that could be attempted is to say that owing to the crisis, all the faithful stand in the Danger of Death "as interpreted in the broad sense of spiritual death", and hence, so it is argued, one can posit that the Church's legislation intends to supply Jurisdiction to all Clergy anywhere who seek to remedy this subjective danger by providing any of the Sacraments practically at will and independent of any concern for the Church's Hierarchy.
The first and most fundamental flaw in Scott's article is the issue that this Canon is not intended for the scenario in question, namely, a Priest without any position of authority, seeking to supply a law for his use of the Sacraments independent of the Catholic Hierarchy (as opposed to, for example, the Diocesan Bishop, who does hold a position of authority to apply Canon 19). As we read in the above definition, this Canon is a provision for those who must establish a norm or judgement for a particular case not foreseen by the Code. This does not refer to an individual without such a position, and hence cannot be used by such a person to determine for himself the existence of a supplied jurisdiction, because he lacks all authority to do so, especially if the analogies drawn by him are fallacious.
This brings us to the next issue: the concept of necessity and danger of death itself. Scott uses the notion found in the Church's law for delegations in cases of a necessity of means to presume a carte blanche extension to any and all devotional administration of the Sacraments that an SSPX Chapel would like to perform at any point in time.
This concept of "necessity" and "danger of death" however, by which the Roman Pontiff supplies Jurisdiction, is not arbitrary but has a concrete and specified meaning not only in the intention of the Legislator but in the usage of the term in the Code itself. Hence, Fr. Scott is forced to create an Analogy of Law for a concept of necessity and danger of death which is not envisioned nor intended by either the Code or the Roman Pontiff as though the two cases were equitable, the first, found in the Code, being the danger of death, the second, manufactured by the SSPX, being the danger of spiritual death, otherwise, any request of the faithful for a devotional administration of the Sacraments to upbuild their personal piety. The fundamental reason these two cases are not equal is clear. Necessity in Canon Law and its application in Danger of Death refers to what is called in Sacramental Theology "necessity of means".
This Necessity means specifically that without this or that Sacrament, here and now, the soul in question stands in proximate danger of the loss of Salvation. Evidently, according to Catholic Theology, such a necessity exists, for example, for the Sacrament of Penance and Baptism in danger of death. That the Legislator certainly intends to confer Jurisdiction for these acts is evident in the entire Corpus of the Church's legislation across the centuries.
The case of a devotional administration of a Sacrament, especially when there are lawful ministers present to the recipient, is not only not comparable to the case of the Danger of Death, but cannot be said to be included in the term necessity in the Law itself or in the intention of the Legislator when they employ this term. Hence, the appeals to analogy fail precisely when the term is extended to cases outside of genuine and imminent danger of the loss of salvation, precisely contrary to the nature and scope of Canon 19; as Wernz & Vidal explain:
In the use of rules of law, each must be applied according to its genuine meaning, and must never be extended to cases that have already been specifically decided in law and in which there is a clear rationale to the contrary. A rule is therefore wrongly applied if what has been established concerning a certain determinate subject is extended to any other subject whatsoever. (Jus Canonicum, Tome I, no. 179)
This is the true meaning of the Code's Canon 1752's "Salus Animarum Suprema Lex"; namely, that when a soul is in proximate danger of the loss of his soul, and thus needs to receive a Sacrament necessary for salvation here and now, the Legislator intends to supply Jurisdiction, particularly by those codes which already address this danger, namely, Canons 976 and 1357.
As such, insofar as we concede that the administration of Sacraments necessary for salvation in danger of death is not comparable to a devotional administration of the Sacraments, and we relied solely on Fr. Scott's appeal to Canon 19, we would find ourselves condemning as "illicit and sacrilegious" a significant portion of the Society's ministry which takes place without such necessity, that is, without necessity as understood by the Law and the Legislator. Indeed, if we wanted to know the exact mind of the Legislator for the particular cases in question, we need only read the Decree of July 2nd issued by the Holy See which states that the Ministries of the Society of St. Pius X are carried out illicitly, that is, without delegation from the Catholic Church.



Comments